"Manhattan Mayhem was a wrestling event promoted by Ring of Honor. It took place on May 7, 2005 at the New Yorker Hotel in New York, New York."
Nelson Rodriguez Erazo
as Homicide
Brandon Silvestry
as Low Ki
Nuufolau Joel Seanoa
as Samoa Joe
Jamar Shipman
as Jay Lethal
Daniel Solwold Jr.
as Austin Aries
Patrick Martin
as Alex Shelley
Phil Brooks
as CM Punk
James Guffey
as Jimmy Rave
Eddie Villa
as Fast Eddie
Davey Andrews
as Himself
Benjamin Whitmer
as BJ Whitmer
Christopher Scoville
as Jimmy Jacobs
Christopher Lindsey
as Roderick Strong
Jack Miller
as Jack Evans
Jamie Noble
John R. Rivera
as Black Tiger
Scott Colton
as Colt Cabana
Steven Haworth
as Nigel McGuinness
Adam Brower
as Izzy
Brandon Garver
Brian Brower
as Dixie
Walter Kirney
as Azrieal